The History of Registered Ankole in South Africa

The History of Registered Ankole in South Africa

By Dr Morné de la Rey, Jacques Malan and Sally Blaine

There is much discussion in the market around what constitutes an Ankole, what is a Watusi and what the difference is.  To understand these differences, it is important to trace back and understand how Ankole became a registered breed in South Africa.  Traditionally Watusi cattle come from Rwanda and are the cattle farmed by the Tutsi tribe.  The Ankole come from Uganda and are farmed by the Nkole tribe.

Watusis in South Africa

In the late 1980’s and early 1990’s there were long-horned cattle from central Africa, (Watusi/Ankole cattle) in zoos in Bloemfontein and the then Port Elizabeth (now Gqeberha). They were generally referred to as Watusi cattle at the time. When these zoos were closed, the cattle were sold to famers in the surrounding areas.  Many, although not all, of these cattle were then successfully crossed with breeds like the Nguni cattle.  The animals from these two zoos, together with Watusis that were imported by Mike Bester, formed the base of the “Watusi” cattle we now have in the country.

In the early 2000’s the farmers who had Watusi cattle registered their animals on SA Studbook.  Part of the offering provided by SA Studbook was certificates to confirm registration of animals on its database.  This registration was often incorrectly understood as constituting registration of the animals with Department of Agriculture, Land Reform and Rural Development (DALRRD).  This has created a significant amount of confusion in the market.  According to mr Joel Mamabolo, the Registrar of Animal Improvement, Watusi is not a registered breed in South Africa in terms of the Animal improvement Act (No 62 of 1998).

How Did Ankole Come into South Africa?

Most people know that Ankole were brought into South Africa by President Ramaphosa and Dr Morné de la Rey after President Ramaphosa fell in love with them after seeing them during a visit to President Museveni in Uganda.  A nucleus herd of Ankole were bought from President Museveni and moved to the approved facility at Ol Pejeta Conservancy in Kenya.  These animals were flushed, and the first embryos were brought into the country and transferred in 2003.

How Did Ankole Become a Recognised Breed in South Africa?

The process for a breed to be recognised in South Africa is defined in the Animal Improvement Act. After an application has been lodged at the Registrar of Animal improvement and it is accepted, he registers the breed as: "a breed under evaluation” Limited genetics in the form of live animals, embryos and semen can be imported and thereafter evaluated to a set of regulations. Since the Directorate of Animal Health only allows embryos from Kenya to be imported to SA, the Ankole genetics were imported in the form of embryos.  Animals are required to go through extensive testing during the full lifecycle (Phases A to D which includes assessment of reproduction, growth rates, weaning weights, ease of calving, on farm performance and central performance testing fertility and breeding soundness evaluation on the bulls) and must achieve specific performance standards to be considered for registration.  Once this has been completed and the animals (hence the breed) performs satisfactorily according to the standards accepted by Animal Improvement and the Agricultural Research Council (ARC), registration must be approved by the Registrar of Animal Improvement and confirmed through an amendment to the Tables to the Animal Improvement Act.  The first Ankole offspring from the embryos brought into South Africa in 2003 were put through all the testing required by Animal Improvement, a sub-directorate of  DALRRD for a breed under evaluation.  Ankole were listed as a breed being evaluated in terms of the Animal Improvement Act Regulations Amendment dated 10 June 2016 and were finally approved as a recognised breed in the amendment published in the Government Gazette in May 2019.

The Role of the Ankole Society of South Africa

Approval of the breed then required that a society be established to manage the improvement of the breed in the country.  This led to the establishment of the Ankole Society of South Africa in 2018.  A breed society can be formed and registered with Animal Improvement when it is a society of a registered breed and has a minimum of seven (7) members.

The first responsibility of the Society was to develop a Constitution, By-Laws and a set of Breed Standards and thereafter registered as the official Ankole Breed Society Animal Improvement within DALRRD.  This included detailing how the pedigrees and animal data would be recorded.  The Ankole Society partnered with the Afrikaner Society, who was a registered service provider to Animal Improvement, and utilised the systems and platforms developed by the Agricultural Research Council as its studbook (Intergis).  All registered Ankole, as defined in the Society’s Constitution and By-Laws, are recorded on Intergis.

Why are Watusi Not Recognised as Ankole?

During the development of the Ankole Society Constitution, By-Laws and Breed Standards, the question of the Watusis in South Africa was raised by the Ankole Council.  A key consideration was how to recognize these animals in relation to the Ankole that had been tested and approved in line with the Animal Improvement Act. The Ankole Council requested  the Watusi to be included in the upgrading programme, but the decision around the recognition and classification of the Watusi rested with the Registrar.  After consideration, the Registrar decided that the Watusi was not a recognised breed in the country.  It had not undergone the performance testing for a breed under evaluation and therefore did not meet the requirements as a recognized breed. It was decided that only Ankole that were brought into South Africa by President Ramaphosa from Uganda could be registered as full blood Ankole.  Therefore, today we can register Ankole whose parentage can be traced back to the original Ankole genetics.

How Does This Impact on the New Genetics?

The Constitution and By-Laws of the Ankole Society make provision for importation of Ankole embryos from recognised Ankole cattle from Uganda or animals that can be traced back to Ugandan Ankole origin.  The importation must be approved by the Ankole  Society  of South Africa in advance.  The animals from which the embryos are being imported must meet all the requirements defined in the Breed Standards and an independent Ankole inspector must confirm that the donor animals (both cows and bulls) phenotypically meet the breed standards.  Genetics of any breed that are imported must be approved by 2 entities of DALRRD namely Animal Improvement and Animal Health. The role the Society plays is to facilitate the regulation of Animal Improvement in line with its registration.

All legal requirements for importation as set out by DALRRD in the importation protocol regarding animal health and animal improvement, must be met before these embryos can be released into the market.  These provisions have been complied with for the new genetics.  These genetics are available from 2024 in South Africa.

What Does This Mean for Watusi and their Offspring?

While there is a significant visual similarity between Watusi and Ankole, the Constitution and By-Laws of the Society require that Ankole must either be traceable to the original animals that were imported by President Ramaphosa or must have been imported in compliance with the relevant legislation and with the approval of the Society and Animal Improvement.  This means that Watusi cattle do not qualify as full blood Ankole.  They can however be bred with fullblood Ankole bulls  through the upgrading system and achieve pure bred status in line with the defined By-Laws of the Society. It is therefore illegal and misleading to sell any animal like Watusi as an Ankole. A person can be sued for misleading information in the civil courts.  The Society is not a regulatory entity and does not have the authority to monitor and regulate this process.  It does have comprehensive records of all registered Ankole, whether fullblood, purebred or an animal registered under the upgrading programme.  The registration status of any animal purchased as an Ankole can be confirmed with the Breed Director, Lauren James.


Ankole Horn Shapes

Ankole Horn Shapes

By Daniel Naude

Ankole horns are striking, distinctive and a large part of what makes the cattle so special.  There are no wrong or right horn shapes.  In Uganda, breeders’ often select and breed for specific horn shapes and you can identify whose herd it is by the shape of the horns.  Here are pictures and illustrations of some of the more common horn shapes.  There are many different horn shapes.  Choose shapes that you find aesthetically pleasing and select and breed for these.

 


The Journey to New Genetics

 The Journey to New Genetics

By Martin Joubert

The beginning of the adventure for my wife, Claire and I started in 2019 with a lengthy 7-hour flight from OR Tambo International Airport in South Africa to Entebbe, Uganda. As we touched down and took in the breathtaking scenery our minds couldn't help but wander to movies like "7 Days in Entebbe" and "Raid on Entebbe". For Claire, and myself, sacrificing holidays and weekends had become a regular occurrence, transforming from an obligation into a way of life. Despite the fatigue and stress, we embraced this journey as a welcomed change which they say is as good as a holiday.

Our first glimpse of Uganda was absolutely mesmerising, as we descended upon the stunning Lake Victoria at Entebbe airport. The vastness of this freshwater lake was so immense that it could easily be mistaken for an ocean. The shores even boasted gentle waves, giving the illusion of a seaside retreat. The lake seemed to stretch endlessly, with no visible end in sight, except for a handful of tiny islands scattered here and there.

From the moment we stepped off the plane, it was evident that Uganda was a country of unparalleled beauty. With areas of abundant rainfall and fertile soil, it was no surprise that the pastoral communities here thrived alongside their cattle. Uganda truly lived up to its title as the pearl of Africa, a land flowing with milk and honey.

Our first encounter outside the airport was with a policeman who seemed and behaved more like a soldier in the Ugandan Army. He shouted orders at us, demanding that we exit the vehicle. Confused, I hesitated, unsure of what I had done wrong. The officer's shouts grew louder as he brandished his AK-47 in our faces. Reluctantly, we complied and watched as he meticulously searched the contents of our vehicle and rummaged through our bags. Finally, he gruffly instructed us to "listen faster" and allowed us to continue on our way.

A contact of ours had warned us about the dangers of Kampala, the capital of Uganda, advising us not to even take our cell phones out of our pockets while in a vehicle, as they were likely to be stolen. The streets were congested with boda-boda motorcycle taxis, notorious for their recklessness, causing traffic to come to a standstill. Motorbikes seemed to be the preferred mode of transport for local Ugandans, while roadside stalls offered an array of fresh produce, including jackfruit, sugarcane, milk, meat, and airtime. It appeared that every Ugandan was an entrepreneur, running their own small business. The sight of Marabou stalks and vultures scattered throughout the city was unsettling, leaving us to wonder what these scavengers feasted upon in the streets.

We soon discovered that Uganda was a country of extreme contrasts. There were times of abundant rainfall, with two rainy seasons each year, followed by periods of harsh drought. We encountered the grandest rivers and lakes we had ever seen, only to stumble upon areas devoid of water for hundreds of kilometres. Uganda's rich culture and heritage were undeniable, but so too was the glaring poverty that surrounded us.

Our search for full blood Ankole cattle began immediately, but we had no clue where to start or which direction to go. Armed with Google Maps and intermittent signal, we selected a few village names and embarked on our journey. The roads were either dirt paths or plagued with potholes, making it treacherous when trucks barrelled towards us head-on, all while navigating around the ever-present cloud of motorbikes. It was the most perilous driving experience of our lives. Unlike other tourists, we were the only ones without a driver and guide by our side. With our rental vehicle, which was a Rav 4 that looked like it was from the 80s, we carved a path through the country relentlessly.

Uganda felt like an entirely different world. Our excitement grew when we spotted what appeared to be Ankole cattle along the roadsides between villages. However, something seemed amiss. Many of the cattle we encountered appeared to be crossbred, lacking the true characteristics of pure Ankole. Some had longer horns, but showed indications that they were a mix with dairy cattle.

Little did we know the mountain of challenges that lay ahead. Some important questions we had to find answers to were:

  • How would we find reputable breeders who could provide us with full blood Ankole?
  • How could we trust strangers in this foreign land?
  • And how could we ensure that the Ankole we acquired were free from diseases?

We had heard tales of farmers being swindled, purchasing large numbers of Ankole only to never receive the promised cattle or hear from the sellers again. These were just a few of the barriers that Claire and I were up against.

After days of futile searching, we finally arrived in a small town in western Uganda, where our most promising contact awaited. This contact had been our lifeline throughout this journey, and we had high hopes for him. He was a businessman and a renowned Ankole rancher, known for his expertise in breeding these majestic cattle. A formidable figure, he stood tall and imposing, always armed and dressed in his signature black cowboy boots and driving his double cab Land Cruiser. This man was truly dedicated to the Ankole breed and a master Ankole breeder.

We met with him several times in a local gathering area, where he grilled us with questions for over an hour each time. Finally, he agreed to take us to see his Ankole cattle. However, there was a catch. He refused to disclose the location of the Ankole, and we were not allowed to drive our own car. Hesitantly, we climbed into his Land Cruiser and embarked on our journey.

We drove for what felt like an eternity, crossing a river that severed our cell phone signals. The rancher shared stories of being deceived and cheated by buyers in the past, which made him cautious when it came to cattle transactions. After another hour of navigating through dirt roads and villages, we finally arrived at an open area. The sign at the entrance read “Royal Ranchers” and this was our first indication that we were close to the Ankole cattle.

Uganda was in the grip of the worst drought it had seen in a century. The rancher hadn't visited his cattle in months, and he feared what condition they might be in. He worried that they may be skeletal and was concerned that many could have died given the lack of rain in the area. Instructing his herdsman, he sent them off into the Ugandan bushveld to fetch the Ankole.

As we waited for the Ankole to appear, I seized the opportunity to ask the rancher all the questions I had accumulated over time. He told us about the cultural importance of these cattle, and shared names of Ankole which described horns and colour variations. With a patient demeanour, he shared his wealth of knowledge with us, I recorded as much as I could. He recounted his own Ankole journey, starting as a young village boy tending to his grandfather's Ankole and eventually becoming a prominent Ugandan businessman. He emphasised the importance of preserving the purity of the Ankole breed, warning against any crossbreeding that would taint their bloodline. With pride, he assured me that I would find no better Ankole in all of Uganda.

As the anticipation built, we eagerly awaited the arrival of the Ankole cattle, hoping that our long and challenging search would finally come to an end.

The sight and sound of over a thousand Ankole cattle emerging from the thickets was a breathtaking and life-changing experience. Their white crescent horns knocking together like the sound of drums, and the calming noises of the cows' bellowing and moving through the veld created an unparalleled ambiance. It was like witnessing a wave from an ocean approaching us. These Ankole were unlike any we had seen before in Uganda, surpassing the ones we had encountered on the roadside whose purity we had doubted. These Ankole were truly extraordinary and immaculately pure.

When the Ankole herd finally arrived in front of us, the rancher was pleasantly surprised by their appearance. I could see the instant joy on his face as if he were a father reuniting with his children after a long absence. Despite their low condition score due to the dry weather, they still looked healthy, strong and resilient. The rancher proudly declared that these cattle were never “spoon-fed”.  For hundreds of years this Ankole bloodline were never fed supplementary feed or ever treated with antibiotics and medicines, but only treated with local herbs and traditional medicines when necessary. They relied largely on their natural instincts and the care of dedicated herdsman. These Ankole were true survivors. I knew then, these are the Ankole genetics that would be an asset to the breed in South Africa.

We meticulously hand-selected a large number of standout Ankole from the massive herd. At his request, we followed the same careful selection process for President Ramaphosa.  With great attention to detail, we examined their horns, horn shapes, phenotype, structural integrity, body balance, and milking abilities.  We were provided with breeding records from the herdsman which reflected a productive and very fertile herd. These Ankole came from two distinct herds with bloodlines that had been passed down through generations in the rancher's family over hundreds of years. The rancher was a true stockman, using only the best Ankole bulls available to breed with his female herds. Bulls were carefully chosen for their superior traits and regularly exchanged with other Ankole ranchers to maintain genetic diversity and minimise inbreeding. For every 100 cows, there were two bulls in each herd, an older bull and a younger one. These bulls were intentionally different from each other, complementing one another. These Ankole were some of the finest in Uganda, with extravagant horn shapes, exceptional balance and quality, and remarkable hardiness.

These Ankole not only exemplified the breed's survival instincts but also represented the breed's exceptional characteristics. The rancher specifically selected for high fertility, milking traits, large frames, beef yield, good body capacity, long average horn length, and horn mass. His Ankole bloodline garnered interest from farmers within Africa and around the world. Personally, I had always favoured mottled Ankole in the past, but seeing a large number of white horns atop the dark red bodies of these Ankole in one area left me awestruck. From that moment on, I knew I would keep two herds, to showcase the beauty of both painted and royal red Ankole.

Now, our focus shifted to sourcing Ankole bulls for our breeding program. It was crucial that these bulls were unrelated to ensure genetic variety and contribute to the future of Ankole in our country. Over the next few days, our sole mission was to find these bulls. However, the environment posed its own challenges. Finding any kind of beef was difficult, and we had to rely on yogurts and apples from garages for sustenance. We even encountered unusual dining experiences, such as being served chicken wings with half the feathers still attached and being asked to assist in catching bats out the kitchen of a restaurant.

Despite the hardships, we persisted, and after a few weeks, we managed to select eight bulls from separate bloodlines in seven different districts along the cattle corridor of Uganda. They were sourced, each from distinct districts of Uganda, including but not limited to Kyankwanzi, Kiruhura, Nakaseke, Sembabule, Nakasongola, Gomba, Mbarara and Masindi. Additionally, we were fortunate to find a bull with the rare brindle coloration, which had caused conflicts among clans due to its uniqueness, this colour was specific to a royal clan and symbolised their identity. It was an emblem of their history and wars and been fought due to ownership of this coloured line.

Each bull possessed its own special and unique traits, setting them apart from one another. Some of these bulls, despite some of their young ages, already had horn sizes comparable to the top Ankole bulls in South Africa. Bringing these new bloodlines to South Africa would be a valuable asset for the local Ankole population and the conservation of the breed.

Throughout this expedition, we encountered numerous challenges, including arranging for the state vet to test the Ankole for diseases. However, the most limiting factor and obstacle was the difficulty in transferring money from South Africa to Uganda. Due to regulations, transactions between the two countries were heavily regulated by the South African Reserve Bank, causing significant delays and complications.

After successfully clearing the cattle of any diseases, we returned to Uganda months later to proceed with the loading process. However, before we could proceed, we had to make the payment to the Ugandan farmer. Unfortunately, the South African Reserve Bank imposed restrictions on sending large amounts of money from South Africa to Uganda without special permission. This posed a problem as obtaining the necessary permission would take an estimated 8 weeks, which we didn't have as our import permits to Kenya were expiring soon.

Despite being in Uganda and ready to load the cattle, we couldn't proceed until the payment reflected in the farmer's account. We anxiously waited, knowing that we had made the payment, but uncertain if the cautious farmer would receive the money. Understandably, he informed us that without the payment reflecting, he couldn't proceed with the transaction due to the financial risk involved. With only two nights left before our permit expired and the loading was scheduled to begin, the payment finally reflected in the farmer's account. However, our rancher had not arranged for any trucks, and the selected bulls had not yet arrived. Moreover, our import permit to Kenya was about to expire on the same day we planned to transport the cattle. The situation became even more critical when we realised the serious time deadlines.

The following morning, we were instructed to meet at the fuel station in town at 6 am. Despite waiting for 4 hours in the rain, there was still no news of any trucks or the Ankole rancher. One could not help then to doubt and question everything that’s happened in anxiety. We later found out that the contact struggled to organise the trucks on such short notice and was, behind the scenes unbeknown to us, working nonstop to get the show on the road.

The Ankole loading started in the rain and the Ankole cattle were reluctant to climb onto trucks as many of their feet had never left the ground in this way in their lives.

The entire day of loading Ankole left us completely penniless, utterly fatigued, drenched by the relentless rain, depleted, and still feeling the lingering effects of last night's ill-fated meal.  Feeling like this, we embarked on our expedition to Kenya.

Claire and I lost a combined 15kg from stress, lack of eating and constant food poisoning.  Our expedition was fraught with hurdles and setbacks. Despite facing financial and bureaucratic obstacles, we remained determined to complete the transaction and transport the cattle to the quarantine facility in Kenya.

We accompanied the Ankole as far as we could in Uganda, but we were warned about the potential negative consequences of our appearance (not being local) at the border and along the journey. It seemed that we would be vulnerable to traffic officers stopping us and demanding exorbitant funds in US dollars in order to continue our journey. Our experiences in Uganda thus far had involved numerous stops and fines, and when we couldn't provide money, they took our food and water. The stress of not knowing the fate of our Ankole or our representatives was unbearable.

Fortunately, our Ankole Rancher had connections which allowed us to communicate, without delay, to necessary role players.  However, another 12 hours passed, and we still hadn't received any updates from the drivers or our representatives. We were unable to reach them or find out what had happened at the border. In the meantime, we drove back from the Ugandan/Kenyan border to the airport in Entebbe during the night. We returned our rental car, boarded a flight to Kenya, arrived in Nairobi, and made our way to Ol Pejeta.

Finally, we received a call informing us that the Ugandan truck drivers had crossed the border into Kenya. However, their cell phones suddenly stopped working because they were unaware that different countries required different SIM cards. This posed a significant problem as we could no longer communicate with our drivers, and the drivers could not use GPS on their phones for directions. They were unfamiliar with the Kenyan road networks, having never driven there before. The trip took even longer than anticipated. We had no idea whether the cattle were still alive, let alone on their way. Everything we had worked for hinged on these cattle arriving safely, and if they didn't, we knew we would never recover from the loss.  Our biggest fear was that the cattle would be hi-jacked and stolen by the truck load.

The estimated 16-hour, 1000-kilometre journey across Africa to Ol Pejeta took close to 3 days. When we saw the trucks approaching on the horizon over the Kenyan plains at Ol Pejeta, it was an overwhelming experience. At that moment, nothing mattered to us except the safety and well-being of the Ankole. As the trucks pulled up to the loading ramps, the condition of the Ankole was indescribable. Claire burst into tears at the sight and frantically ran back and forth with water buckets, providing much-needed hydration to the weak cows. Meanwhile, I coordinated the safe offloading of these incredibly fragile Ankole. It was a heart-wrenching and rewarding experience at the same time.

After witnessing the hundreds of trucks filled with Ankole in Uganda heading to the abattoir and witnessing the extent of crossbreeding, I became convinced that the Ankole breed in Uganda would become extinct in less than the predicted 20 years. Although this journey for the cattle was arduous, our solace came from knowing that it was essential for the conservation of the Ankole breed and its precious bloodlines. Against all odds, they had finally made it, and we had succeeded. However, the journey was far from over. The Ankole now had to survive in the vast 36,000-hectare Ol Pejeta conservancy in Kenya, where lion, leopard, cheetah, hyena, and elephant roamed freely. The only protection they had was a Maasai herdsman with a stick standing between them and the wildlife.

In Kenya, the Ankole faced a daunting requirement.  They had to secure Kenyan residency in order to be eligible for embryo production. This meant they had to survive among the big 5 wildlife in the Ol Pejeta conservancy for over a year. It was a challenging time for the cattle, who had already gone through a demanding journey. They now had to endure the harshness of the conservancy, filled with an array of dangers, including predators, before entering the quarantine centre. The fact that these cattle had not encountered predators before made this an extremely dangerous situation for them.

Unfortunately, the management and staff of Ol Pejeta saw us only as third-party grazers and showed little concern for the welfare of the cattle, despite us being paying clients and supporting the embryo station.

During the flushing process, we encountered various obstacles. Some Ankole donor cows produced excellent results, with flushes yielding ten times more embryos than  we had seen in South Africa. However, other cows did not produce any embryos at all. The cost of flushing in Kenya was significantly higher than in South Africa and had to be paid whether the cows flushed embryos or not.

Over the years, many cows died due to circumstances beyond our control. It was a situation we had to accept, although it was heartbreaking.

After a year of flushing, we were ecstatic that viable embryos were obtained.  However there were delays caused by bureaucratic processes between Kenya and South Africa, extending until late 2023.

Once the embryos were cleared for import, , we faced the highest stakes and highest risk. I was reminded of a story shared by a Boran breeder years ago, where his efforts to bring in Boran embryos from Kenya ended in disaster when his flask of embryos stored in liquid nitrogen capsized during the return flight. He unfortunately lost most of the embryos and could only produce one calf.

Nothing would have been possible without the tireless efforts of Dr. Morné de la Rey from Embryo Plus, who has been dedicated, for decades, to the conservation of the Ankole breed. No problem or obstacle, no matter how many or how frequent over the years were too great for him to overcome.  Luck was on our side and fortunately our flasks had withstood the flight to South Africa.

Once the embryos safely arrived, we experienced delays in South Africa, which lasted almost a year. Finally, in December 2023, the first embryos were transferred while going through government-mandated quarantine.

Through the passage of this timeline over the years, the investment of resources was significant , and the challenges we faced were both uplifting and disheartening. We nevertheless feel comfort in the knowledge that we have made a significant contribution to the preservation of this precious and exquisite breed.

Considering the effort throughout this endeavour, we had to make a responsible decision in determining the best way forward for the benefit of the embryos and the Ankole breed.  Our objective was to ensure the successful birth of as many calves as possible after the transfer process.  It was crucial for us to partner with a breeder who possessed exceptional facilities, extensive knowledge of the embryo process and expertise in pregnancy and calf management.

After careful consideration, we decided to join forces with Anton De Swardt and Sally Blaine from Ubhejane Wildlife.  This collaboration has proven to be a perfect match, as our shared vision for the new genetics project has flourished with immense potential and promise.

Over the years, we have developed a relationship with Anton and Sally and witnessed their exceptional expertise in managing a prime embryo facility and executing embryo processes from preparation of recipients to calving with the utmost professionalism.

We share a deep passion for Ankole and trust in Anton and Sally to continue the journey with us. Our anticipation grows as we eagerly await the arrival of the first Ankole calves of these bloodlines to take their monumental first steps on South African soil in 2024.

Post Script

At the time of writing of this article, the release of the recipient cows from quarantine had just been approved by the South African Veterinary authorities.  This is the culmination of five years’ worth of work from the three breeders and Dr Morné de la Rey and his team at Embryo Plus who invested emotionally and financially in bringing new genetics into South Africa.  To give you a sense of the financial investment to produce the embryos, here are some of the costs incurred by the breeders:

  • Disease testing in Ol Pejeta, Kenya at the approximately cost of R5000 a donor animal.
  • Flushing costs, per flush, of USD 1950. 124 Ankole cattle were flushed.

Quarantine costs incurred in South Africa have included feeding approximately 500 cattle at R90 a head a day. This amounts to R45 000 daily feeding costs.  The animals have been in quarantine since late October, early November 2023.  This is approximately R6 750 000 in feeding costs alone.  This excludes the testing costs that must be done on all cattle in quarantine.  All recipients were tested for Foot and Mouth Disease, Brucellosis and Contagious Bovine Pleuropneumonia on day 0, day 21, day 42 and day 60.  This battery of tests cost approximately R2500 per animal per round of testing.  There are also all the medicine preparation costs for all the recipient cows.  The financial costs have run into millions.

As Ankole breeders, we are indebted to the intrepid breeders and vets who undertook this perilous journey.  The new genetics are essential to building diversity in our South African herds and to our commitment to the conservation, improvement and growth of this magnificent breed.


Ankole Cattle - The Business Case

ANKOLE CATTLE  – THE BUSINESS CASE

By Anton De Swardt

Sally and I started with intensive breeding of sable antelope, nyala and buffalo on our game farm in the Bela Bela area in Limpopo in 2007. Although we always loved the game breeding and had lots of fun, it never provided a solid return on investment since we never considered it, nor farmed it as a commercial agricultural operation. With a sharp decline in game prices, we decided that we had to adapt to ensure that we would still have a proper revenue stream on the farm and for us, going into Ankole breeding was the obvious and logical next step.

We started our Ankole herd with the purchase of four females and two implanted recipients in 2020. We knew, from the game industry, that genetics is almost everything. Our first goal was really obtaining the best genetics we could afford and hence buying recipients certified pregnant with embryos from the top bull, Tshinakaho, and a top cow, Lindi, was the most affordable way of obtaining such genetics. This proved to be one of the best decisions we could have made.

WHY ANKOLE?

Our farm is located in the Bela Bela area with extremely harsh bushveld conditions that present many risks for cattle. We have all the known, and some unknown tickborne diseases including hart water, red water, anaplasmosis and others. Ordinary cattle are challenged with pink eye caused by moraxella (infectious bovine keratoconjunctivitis.) We have very hot summers, very cold winters and often have long dry spells.

Ankole are true African cattle born and bred in Africa with all it’s natural challenges. Ankole cattle are not only able to survive but can thrive in our harsh veld conditions with minimal human intervention and treatment.  As such, they make an excellent choice for extensive breeding where a bull and some females are used in ordinary veld conditions.

BREED CATTLE

People generally classify cattle as either beef or dairy and the question is often posed – where do Ankole fit in? This is generally a European approach. It is important to understand that, in Africa, cattle are currency. For indigenous African people cattle are their gold standard and, as such, fulfil a very different market function than simply beef or dairy.

Ankole cattle, with their huge, impressive horns in multiple different shapes and coat colours ranging between dark liver brown to spectacular mottled colours, evoke a passionate response and reaction. The value of Ankole is significantly influenced by their scarcity and desirability. Stud breeding of Ankole in South Africa is in its infancy and it makes for very interesting reading when comparing the numbers with those of other stud cattle breeds.

According to Stats South Africa there are approximately 13,9 million cattle in South Africa with approximately 60% being held by commercial farmers and small-holders and 40% in rural communal communities.

The following comparisons of rounded numbers can be considered:

Breed Registered Stud Breeders Registered Stud Cattle Commercial Cattle
Boran 280 42 000+
Nguni 145 19 000+ 40 000+
Angus 140 21 000+
Brahman 370 46 000
Bonsmara 60 000 4 000 000

 

In sharp contrast, the current statistics for Ankole cattle are as follows:

  • Registered Stud Breeders:           62
  • Registered Stud Cattle: 1792 of which 1198 are Fullblood registered

MARKET VALUE OF ANKOLE

A significant part of the business case for Ankole is the market value of stud animals.  The data provided below shows that Ankole prices fair very well when considered against some of the other breeds in South Africa.  They also show that the prices are relatively constant, year on year.

Description Average Ankole Prices March 2023 Average Ankole Prices March 2024 Average Boran Prices March 2023
Cows R316,667 R320,000 R59,667
Bulls R151,250 R131,000 R63,333
Heifers R330,000 R300,000 R172,500
Cows with calves R415,000 R164,000
Pregnant cow with calf R1,800,000
Frozen embryos R52,000
Pregnant recipients R418,750
Semen per straw R30,800

 

The March 2024 pregnant recipients obtained record prices because it included implanted recipients sold with new genetics from Uganda imported through Kenya by Embryo Plus.  These genetics are completely unrelated to the existing genetics in South Africa.

The Ankole stud bull prices compare well with other breeds in the country.  This is clear from the prices achieved since 2020.  .

Breed Price Date Seller
Ankole R3,000,000 April 2021 Twin City
Ankole R1,650,000 June 2022 Benella Ankole
Ankole R1,000,000 June 2022 W2 Ankole
Boran R2,300,000 August 2022 Hurwitz Farming
Boran R1,700,000 July 2020 Meybor Boran Stud
Boran R1,500,000 August 2022 Hurwitz Farming
Boran R1,400,000 August 2022 Hurwitz Farming
Bonsmara R2,100,000 June 2022 Poggepoel Molopo Bonsmaras
Beefmaster R1,100,000 June 2021 Bos Blanco Beefmaster Stud
Limousin R1,200,000 May 2022 Devlan Limousins
Bonsmara R4,400,000 July 2023 Up George Bonsmaras
Bonsmara R2,000,000 July 2023 Up George Bonsmaras

 

The cows do just as well as is illustrated with the prices achieved between 2021 to date.

Description Price Date Seller
Ankole heifer R2,100,000 March 2022 Ntaba Nyoni
Ankole cow with heifer calf R2,000,000 September 2021 Ntaba Nyoni
Ankole cow with heifer calf R1,800,000 March 2024 Ntaba Nyoni
Ankole cow R1,500,000 September 2021 Ntaba Nyoni
Ankole cow R1,265,000 April 2023 Benella Ankole
Ankole heifer R950,000 June 2022 Embryo Plus
Ankole cow R850,000 September 2022 Ntaba Nyoni
Boran cow with calf R1,100,000 August 2022 Hurwitz Farming
Boran pregnant heifer R650,000 August 2022 Hurwitz Farming

 

INVESTMENT CONSIDERATIONS

Some things to consider when looking considering investing in Ankole are:

  • It has been proven over decades and across all breeds that top quality animals will get excellent prices regardless of the breed.
  • The fact that the top genetic Ankole cattle achieve excellent prices is aligned with the general market trend across all cattle breeds.
  • Other than the Bonsmara bull record price of R4.4 million achieved in 2023, Ankole holds the SA record prices across all categories of pregnant cows with calves, cows, heifers, pregnant recipients and semen.
  • Considering the history of prices in the cattle industry, it is obvious that quality matters and that breeding up is essential.
  • The market for Ankole cattle in South Africa and in the SADC region is large. This was demonstrated by the diversity in the buyers at the last Ntaba Nyoni Auction of 2023.  Breeders from Zambia, Zimbabwe and Mozambique bought Ankole at this auction.  60% of all lots were purchased by Black buyers.
  • Ankole stud breeding in South Africa is in its infancy. Investing now means getting into a great market with huge growth potential early.
  • Ankole have value beyond their meat and milk production – they are aptly regarded as the African gold standard! They are regarded as a multi-purpose breed.
  • They are very well suited for farming in Africa. They are hardy, disease resistant and do well on marginal agricultural land.  They will thrive in the same conditions as game.  This makes them a perfect partner for game farmers.
  • Ankole can be farmed either in extensive farm land with minimal human intervention or treatment. They are equally suitable for intensive breeding with the use of artificial insemination and embryo transplants.
  • There is substantial growth and interest in the use of Ankole in eco-tourism. They are majestic creatures that always make a positive impression.
  • As Ankole numbers increase, the prices will decrease, but top quality animals will always remain a strong investment with excellent returns.

When all factors are weighed up, investing in Ankole made sense for us because they do well in our veld, require limited management, there is excellent market growth potential and they provide an excellent return.  In addition to this, they are magnificent creatures and working with them is a privilege and pleasure.  We are confident that our investment will make excellent returns.